Is your Website Legal? ( Full Article )
The COVID-19 pandemic has tilted the world of commerce decidedly—and
perhaps irrevocably—toward a model where the fundamental point of
contact between consumer and business is online. Put simply, a
restaurant these days needs a website just as much as a kitchen, in
order for customers to place pick-up or delivery orders consistent with
physical distancing directives. An orchestra needs a way to deliver
performances to audiences while concert halls are closed to crowds. An
academy needs virtual classroom settings where teachers and students can
communicate, assign and turn in homework, and give and take tests.
As a practical matter, these changes will translate into myriad new
websites, novel digital content, and an increase in online consumer
traffic. Each new website, however, is a risk, for each one represents a
potential lawsuit. Specifically, every time a business creates a new
digital interface with consumers, there will be an active bar of
litigants examining that website for shortcomings under the World Wide
Web Consortium’s Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG)—and
preparing a corresponding demand letter or lawsuit asserting a digital
accessibility violation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
and analogous state disability discrimination laws.
Last year, even before the COVID-19 pandemic, over 10,000 such
lawsuits were filed in the federal courts alone. That inventory of
litigation will only increase as businesses throughout the United States
race to build out new online ordering, communication tools, mobile
apps, and other digital service offerings.
The theory of liability for these lawsuits is a hybrid of disability
discrimination law grafted onto the increasing prevalence of web-based
commerce. The ADA requires that places of public accommodation provide
access to disabled persons. Places of public accommodation include
privately owned facilities used in interstate commerce, from restaurants
to concert halls, to accountants’ offices and hospitals. The ADA was
enacted when the world of commerce was largely physical in form: dining
rooms with paper menus, storefronts with consumer products to take off
the shelf. But as businesses went online, and consumers grew
increasingly reliant on websites for information, for communication, and
for core business transactions themselves, disabled persons began to
contend that the ADA required adequate access not only in physical, but
also in digital, contexts.

The strong form of this argument is that a website is itself a place
of public accommodation. The weaker (and more common) form of this
argument is that the ADA mandates adequate access to a business’s
website because it functions as an essential nexus to the services
offered by that business’s “real world” place of public accommodation,
whether it be a department store or a pharmacy. In our current world of
physical distancing, the increased restrictions on direct access to
physical places of public accommodation will inevitably lead to a
correspondingly increased emphasis on remote access to online services.
With this increase in web-based commerce will come another wave of ADA
website accessibility litigation.
What does access mean in the context of a consumer using a website?
When a blind consumer is in front of a computer screen, a mouse—whose
purpose is to position an arrow on the screen, to select links on the
screen to follow, and to click on those links—is not helpful. Instead,
that user needs to access the content of the webpage a different way.
The digital analogue to Braille is a screen reader. Instead of
maneuvering a mouse corresponding to a screen arrow, a blind website
user uses the computer’s keyboard to move around the website, in
combination with a screen reader that will voice the content of the
website. But the screen reader can only read out content that has been
coded properly into the website’s underlying source code.
Instead of following a layout of fields and links and colors on the
screen, a blind user using a keyboard and screen reader can also access
the structure of the website, but only if that information has
been properly coded into the website’s underlying HTML. And when a deaf
consumer is presented with website content that is aural—for example, a
video—she will need proper captioning to access that information.
Any company’s website or mobile app can therefore serve as the “hook”
for an ADA digital accessibility lawsuit. That said, it is important to
keep in mind that the only substantive remedy provided by the ADA is
injunctive relief. If such injunctive changes are ordered by a court,
they can then form the basis for a motion for attorneys’ fees to be paid
by the defendant. In contrast, depending on the jurisdiction, state law
disability discrimination laws may provide for additional remedies,
such as damages. While they are rushing to roll out new websites and
other online services, businesses should take care to design their new
digital offerings to minimize claims that they provide inadequate access
to disabled users.
First, businesses should work with their counsel to craft a
company-wide accessibility policy committing to WCAG standards. A
business without such a corporate accessibility policy will be viewed by
a court as more likely to lapse into technical deficiencies, and thus
more deserving of a court injunction.
Second, where new digital content has already been rolled out to the
public, businesses should invest in a website accessibility audit.
Companies can preserve privilege and work product protections over audit
papers where the analysis is conducted under the direction of counsel
by a consulting accessibility expert.
Third, businesses should create a record that their IT personnel has
been trained in WCAG guidelines, and they should schedule periodic
training sessions in light of the continual updates to technical
accessibility specifications.
Fourth, where feasible, businesses should design any new
customer-facing digital content from the ground up so that it is
consistent with accessible design principles. These include, for
example, ensuring that website content is keyboard accessible; has
properly coded structure information that is usable by blind consumers,
such as skip links and landmarks; and has usable labeling of fillable
forms and other features, particularly ones that function as points of
contact for commercial transactions.
While the world is unfortunately uncertain whether there will be
follow-on waves of COVID-19, one thing that is certain is that there
will be substantial waves of COVID-19-based litigation in the United
States. One such wave will almost certainly target the multitude of new
web-based service offerings necessitated by the pandemic. Given the
predictable risk of website accessibility litigation in this new world
of increased online commerce, businesses can and should work with their
counsel to take appropriate prophylactic measures.
Rocky Tsai, a partner in the San Francisco office of Ropes &
Gray, counsels financial, technology and life sciences clients in
complex disputes and litigation risk management, with a particular
emphasis in multi-forum and class action litigation. For years, he has
worked closely with the National Center for Accessible Media on website
accessibility audits and remediation concerning the digital assets of
major consumer brands, financial institutions, and entertainment content
providers.
perhaps irrevocably—toward a model where the fundamental point of
contact between consumer and business is online. Put simply, a
restaurant these days needs a website just as much as a kitchen, in
order for customers to place pick-up or delivery orders consistent with
physical distancing directives. An orchestra needs a way to deliver
performances to audiences while concert halls are closed to crowds. An
academy needs virtual classroom settings where teachers and students can
communicate, assign and turn in homework, and give and take tests.
As a practical matter, these changes will translate into myriad new
websites, novel digital content, and an increase in online consumer
traffic. Each new website, however, is a risk, for each one represents a
potential lawsuit. Specifically, every time a business creates a new
digital interface with consumers, there will be an active bar of
litigants examining that website for shortcomings under the World Wide
Web Consortium’s Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG)—and
preparing a corresponding demand letter or lawsuit asserting a digital
accessibility violation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
and analogous state disability discrimination laws.
Last year, even before the COVID-19 pandemic, over 10,000 such
lawsuits were filed in the federal courts alone. That inventory of
litigation will only increase as businesses throughout the United States
race to build out new online ordering, communication tools, mobile
apps, and other digital service offerings.
The theory of liability for these lawsuits is a hybrid of disability
discrimination law grafted onto the increasing prevalence of web-based
commerce. The ADA requires that places of public accommodation provide
access to disabled persons. Places of public accommodation include
privately owned facilities used in interstate commerce, from restaurants
to concert halls, to accountants’ offices and hospitals. The ADA was
enacted when the world of commerce was largely physical in form: dining
rooms with paper menus, storefronts with consumer products to take off
the shelf. But as businesses went online, and consumers grew
increasingly reliant on websites for information, for communication, and
for core business transactions themselves, disabled persons began to
contend that the ADA required adequate access not only in physical, but
also in digital, contexts.

Electronic DiscoveryBook
Discusses the legal and practical challenges involved in
e-discovery: the discovery process; evidentiary issues; and strategies
tactics in litigation.
Get More Information
e-discovery: the discovery process; evidentiary issues; and strategies
tactics in litigation.
Get More Information
of public accommodation. The weaker (and more common) form of this
argument is that the ADA mandates adequate access to a business’s
website because it functions as an essential nexus to the services
offered by that business’s “real world” place of public accommodation,
whether it be a department store or a pharmacy. In our current world of
physical distancing, the increased restrictions on direct access to
physical places of public accommodation will inevitably lead to a
correspondingly increased emphasis on remote access to online services.
With this increase in web-based commerce will come another wave of ADA
website accessibility litigation.
What does access mean in the context of a consumer using a website?
When a blind consumer is in front of a computer screen, a mouse—whose
purpose is to position an arrow on the screen, to select links on the
screen to follow, and to click on those links—is not helpful. Instead,
that user needs to access the content of the webpage a different way.
The digital analogue to Braille is a screen reader. Instead of
maneuvering a mouse corresponding to a screen arrow, a blind website
user uses the computer’s keyboard to move around the website, in
combination with a screen reader that will voice the content of the
website. But the screen reader can only read out content that has been
coded properly into the website’s underlying source code.
Instead of following a layout of fields and links and colors on the
screen, a blind user using a keyboard and screen reader can also access
the structure of the website, but only if that information has
been properly coded into the website’s underlying HTML. And when a deaf
consumer is presented with website content that is aural—for example, a
video—she will need proper captioning to access that information.
Any company’s website or mobile app can therefore serve as the “hook”
for an ADA digital accessibility lawsuit. That said, it is important to
keep in mind that the only substantive remedy provided by the ADA is
injunctive relief. If such injunctive changes are ordered by a court,
they can then form the basis for a motion for attorneys’ fees to be paid
by the defendant. In contrast, depending on the jurisdiction, state law
disability discrimination laws may provide for additional remedies,
such as damages. While they are rushing to roll out new websites and
other online services, businesses should take care to design their new
digital offerings to minimize claims that they provide inadequate access
to disabled users.
First, businesses should work with their counsel to craft a
company-wide accessibility policy committing to WCAG standards. A
business without such a corporate accessibility policy will be viewed by
a court as more likely to lapse into technical deficiencies, and thus
more deserving of a court injunction.
Second, where new digital content has already been rolled out to the
public, businesses should invest in a website accessibility audit.
Companies can preserve privilege and work product protections over audit
papers where the analysis is conducted under the direction of counsel
by a consulting accessibility expert.
Third, businesses should create a record that their IT personnel has
been trained in WCAG guidelines, and they should schedule periodic
training sessions in light of the continual updates to technical
accessibility specifications.
Fourth, where feasible, businesses should design any new
customer-facing digital content from the ground up so that it is
consistent with accessible design principles. These include, for
example, ensuring that website content is keyboard accessible; has
properly coded structure information that is usable by blind consumers,
such as skip links and landmarks; and has usable labeling of fillable
forms and other features, particularly ones that function as points of
contact for commercial transactions.
While the world is unfortunately uncertain whether there will be
follow-on waves of COVID-19, one thing that is certain is that there
will be substantial waves of COVID-19-based litigation in the United
States. One such wave will almost certainly target the multitude of new
web-based service offerings necessitated by the pandemic. Given the
predictable risk of website accessibility litigation in this new world
of increased online commerce, businesses can and should work with their
counsel to take appropriate prophylactic measures.
Rocky Tsai, a partner in the San Francisco office of Ropes &
Gray, counsels financial, technology and life sciences clients in
complex disputes and litigation risk management, with a particular
emphasis in multi-forum and class action litigation. For years, he has
worked closely with the National Center for Accessible Media on website
accessibility audits and remediation concerning the digital assets of
major consumer brands, financial institutions, and entertainment content
providers.
Comments
Post a Comment